Written by Ethan Walker · Reviewed against our Editorial Guidelines · Updated September 23, 2026

What to Put on a Lick Mat for Dogs (25+ Safe Ideas)

The best things to put on a lick mat are soft, spreadable, dog-safe foods — plain yogurt, mashed pumpkin, wet food, or xylitol-free peanut butter — smeared thin enough that your dog has to work for every lick. Past that, the specific food matters much less than people assume.

Below: the full list by category, what to avoid, a few combinations worth the extra thirty seconds, and the freezing trick that turns a two-minute snack into a proper activity. If you're new to lick mats generally — what they do, why dogs find them calming, how to clean them — start with our lick mats for dogs guide. And if the dog in question is still a puppy, settle the age question first: when puppies can have lick mats.

Texture beats recipe, every time

Search "lick mat recipes" and you'll find eight-ingredient layered parfaits photographed like dessert. They're lovely. Your dog cannot tell the difference between one of those and a tablespoon of their own wet food spread properly into the grooves.

What decides whether a mat holds a dog's attention for one minute or fifteen is texture and thickness — how far the filling gets pushed into the ridges, and whether it's been frozen. So there are only two questions worth asking about any filling: is it safe, and does it spread? Everything below passes both tests, sorted by where you'll probably find it.

Safe lick mat fillings, by category

Everything here should be plain and unseasoned. No added salt, no sugar, no spice blends, nothing prepared for human palates.

Dairy, in moderation

Plain unsweetened yogurt is the most-used filling for good reason: thick, spreads beautifully into a textured surface, and most dogs are enthusiastic about it. Dairy tolerance varies between individual dogs, so start small and see how your dog's stomach handles it before it becomes a habit.

Plain, unsweetened yogurt
Plain cottage cheese
A thin smear of plain cream cheese
Plain, unsweetened kefir (thinner than yogurt — good for layering under something thicker)

Fruit and vegetables

The category most owners underuse. Mashed or pureed produce spreads well, is low in calories, and gives you variety without leaning on peanut butter every time.

Mashed banana
Plain canned pumpkin puree — check the label says pumpkin only, not pumpkin pie filling, which carries added sugar and spices
Cooked, mashed sweet potato (skin removed)
Mashed blueberries
Cooked, mashed carrot
Steamed and mashed green beans
Cooked, mashed butternut squash (plain, no butter or seasoning)
Unsweetened applesauce, or fresh apple mashed with the core and seeds removed

Proteins

Wet dog food — genuinely the easiest option, and the only one on this page already balanced for your dog
Plain boiled and mashed chicken or turkey, no seasoning and no bones
Unsalted, onion-free bone broth, frozen into the ridges
Xylitol-free peanut butter, thin layer only
Plain scrambled egg, cooked without butter or salt, mashed fine
A small amount of tinned sardines in water (no salt added), mashed

Mixtures

A wet base plus something dry adds resistance, which is the entire point. Wet food with a few pieces of kibble pressed into the grooves lasts noticeably longer than wet food alone. Plain cooked rice loosened with pumpkin or unsalted broth works the same way, as does softening your dog's regular kibble in warm water and mashing it to a paste — free, and it counts cleanly as part of a meal rather than an extra.

However you fill it, what goes on the mat comes out of your dog's daily food allowance, not on top of it. A generously loaded mat every afternoon adds up faster than owners expect.

What should never go on a lick mat

Start with xylitol, because it's the one that catches careful owners out. It's a sugar substitute that's genuinely toxic to dogs in small amounts, and it turns up where you wouldn't check: some "natural" peanut butters, some flavoured yogurts, most sugar-free products. Brands reformulate without announcing it, so a jar you've safely used for two years can change. Read the label every time you buy, not just the first time.

The rest is the usual toxicity roll call, and it applies here exactly as it would anywhere else:

Chocolate, grapes, and raisins — toxic to dogs
Onion and garlic — toxic in more than trace amounts, which rules out most stock cubes and prepared broths
Excess salt — skip anything salted, cured, or seasoned for people
Cooked bones — not really a filling, but worth repeating anywhere dog food is discussed: they splinter

One more, less obvious: don't debut a brand-new food on a mat right before something stressful. If you're loading it to get through a bath or a vet visit, that's the worst possible moment to discover your dog doesn't tolerate cottage cheese. Test anything new on an ordinary day first.

Five combinations worth the extra thirty seconds

Peanut butter and banana. Mash a little banana into a thin layer of xylitol-free peanut butter. Good texture contrast, and the banana stretches a small amount of peanut butter much further.
Pumpkin and yogurt, layered. Pumpkin as a base, yogurt over the top. Two thin layers give a dog more to work through than one thick one.
Wet food loosened with broth. Thin a spoonful of wet food with unsalted bone broth until it's almost runny. It works deeper into the grooves, so it takes longer to get back out.
Cottage cheese with mashed blueberries. Low effort, easy on the calorie count.
Kibble crumble. Grind a handful of your dog's usual kibble and stir it through yogurt or wet food. The grit gives the tongue something to fight, and it's the cheapest upgrade here.

Freezing is the whole trick

If you take one thing from this page, take this: freezing a loaded mat is the difference between a snack and an activity. A room-temperature smear of yogurt disappears in about ninety seconds. Frozen solid, the same yogurt can hold a dog's attention for fifteen or twenty minutes, because they have to thaw it as they go. Twenty to thirty minutes in the freezer usually does it; longer does no harm and is worth it in summer, or before a grooming session you know will drag.

Three things matter more than what you filled it with:

Spread it thin. A blob in the middle is a two-second snack. A thin film across the whole surface is a session.
Use the ridges, not the flat. Push filling down into the texture with the back of a spoon. That resistance is the product — the mat isn't a plate.
Layer instead of piling. Two thin layers of different foods outlast one thick layer of a single one.

A quick, honest note about what we sell

Same disclosure as our main lick mat guide: we don't make a lick mat. We're not going to pretend otherwise halfway down a page about filling one.

What we do make is a snuffle mat, which chases the same goal from a different direction — dry kibble hidden in fleece folds for your dog to sniff out, rather than soft food to lick off. Nose instead of tongue, and it goes in the washing machine, which anyone who has scraped dried peanut butter out of silicone grooves will appreciate. Plenty of owners keep both: a lick mat for calming down, a snuffle mat for the "give me a job" hours. Our dog enrichment ideas guide covers the wider toolkit.

👉 See the Snuffle Mat for Dogs →

Frequently Asked Questions

What can I put on a lick mat besides peanut butter? Plain yogurt, mashed pumpkin, wet dog food, mashed banana, cottage cheese, mashed sweet potato, or unsalted bone broth all work well. The requirement is a soft, spreadable, dog-safe texture — peanut butter is popular but nowhere near the only option, and rotating keeps it more interesting for your dog.

Can I put raw meat on a lick mat? Plain, boiled, unseasoned meat is the simpler choice for most home setups, since raw meat brings bacterial handling considerations and needs immediate, thorough cleanup of the mat and the surface it sat on. If you already feed raw and are comfortable with those precautions, apply the same ones here.

How do I make a DIY frozen lick mat? Spread a thin layer of a safe filling — yogurt, pumpkin, or wet food — across the ridges, then freeze the mat flat for 20 to 30 minutes or longer. That's the whole method, and it's what turns a quick snack into a genuinely long activity.

Is peanut butter safe for dogs on a lick mat? Only if it's xylitol-free. Xylitol is toxic to dogs and appears in some "natural" and sugar-free peanut butters. Check the label every time you buy a jar, including on a brand you've used before, because manufacturers do change formulations without warning.